Servers Unavailable

Nice launch there Bungie.

#alwaysonline

locked

1803 views

Nice launch there Bungie.

#alwaysonline

Same here.

locked

1700 views

Nice launch there Bungie.

#alwaysonline

Same here.

ditto

locked

1710 views

This week at Bungie we’re ready.

Clearly not.

locked

1750 views

Nice launch there Bungie.

#alwaysonline

Same here.

ditto

Yep.

locked

1678 views

Shock!

;-)

locked

1678 views

Shock!

;-)

It says to post in the help forum if you are having problems.

1. I can't log in to bnet so I can't post.
2. There is an ad for Kontrol Freaks on the BNET forum in the sidebar despite my ad blocker.

Never going to Bungie's forums ever again. Ads on a company website are unacceptable.

Whole lotta bullshit now. Unhappy customer.

locked

1706 views

It says to post in the help forum if you are having problems.

1. I can't log in to bnet so I can't post.

This is really annoying

2. There is an ad for Kontrol Freaks on the BNET forum in the sidebar despite my ad blocker.

I don't understand the specifics of how ad blockers work. but mine does not catch this one either. With that said, It links to the bungie store with all profits going to charity. so that doesn't bother me in this case.

locked

1696 views

It says to post in the help forum if you are having problems.

1. I can't log in to bnet so I can't post.

I know, right?! XD I said the exact same thing.

2. There is an ad for Kontrol Freaks on the BNET forum in the sidebar despite my ad blocker.

I've never seen one, but honestly that does seem a little weird for them...

I'm kind of on a gloat boat though, so I'm not really upset.

Ohh, Bungie--what am I gonna do with you? (ruffles hair)

locked

1718 views

- No text -

locked

1666 views

- No text -

locked

1638 views

I think its pretty awesome. Spoilers!!!! It has moving snow and Saladin's axe flame moves as well.

locked

1674 views

I think its pretty awesome. Spoilers!!!! It has moving snow and Saladin's axe flame moves as well.

The theme's been available for a few weeks now... And yeh, it's a really cool theme.

locked

1598 views

I'm in the queue! ...along with 41,902 others...

...now down to 39,042

locked

1684 views

I'm in the queue! ...along with 41,902 others...

...now down to 39,042

Yup, just got that. I'm 72,117.

locked

1674 views

117363.

Think it's going to be a bit...longer.

*update

133377. I think it is going in the wrong direction. :/

locked

1666 views

126626.... almost there

locked

1664 views

Sweet jesus, I haven't laughed this hard since the Hotel mega-fight. ;-D

I've never seen this before in my life, and I love it!

locked

1673 views

- No text -

locked

1638 views

- No text -

locked

1648 views

126k. Should have known better than to wander off and do something else while we wait.

For those not in the know, Im the English one. We like queues. #dontexplainthejoke

locked

1698 views

Charlie moved up 100k in the time I've moved 10.

That's not how queues work Bungie.

locked

1662 views

I just got booted and moved back 100k spaces

locked

1653 views

I'm honestly disgusted at myself for being a part of the addicts in line waiting for a fix, but here I am. 105,000 and counting down until I get error code'd out of line.

locked

1660 views

- No text -

locked

1663 views

- No text -

locked

1625 views

[image]

locked

1648 views

Soothing, entertaining and even a bit educational at times.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNlMUuwXJAs

locked

1702 views

- No text -

locked

1629 views

- No text -

locked

1640 views

- No text -

locked

1644 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

locked

1694 views

It's 10AM here, I'm supposed to be up and clogging the servers. You'll get plenty of time for that later :p

locked

1645 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

Some of the reactions in this thread are more rage-inducing to me than any failure on Bungie's part.

locked

1667 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

Some of the reactions in this thread are more rage-inducing to me than any failure on Bungie's part.

In that case, don't look at the subreddit.

locked

1595 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

Some of the reactions in this thread are more rage-inducing to me than any failure on Bungie's part.

It's perfectly justified. Travel back in time to 1985 and tell someone you have to wait in line to play a game on your home console. They would laugh and call you crazy.

Because it is crazy, and people who are okay with it are bad people and not helping.

locked

1624 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

Some of the reactions in this thread are more rage-inducing to me than any failure on Bungie's part.

It's perfectly justified. Travel back in time to 1985 and tell someone you have to wait in line to play a game on your home console where you are playing with millions of other people on their home console over this magical thing called the internet. They would laugh and call you crazy.

Because it is crazy and amazing, and people who are okay with it are bad people and not helping.

I'm laughing at you because you and your hard line stances ignore so many other parts of reality.

locked

1598 views

It's perfectly justified. Travel back in time to 1985 and tell someone you have to wait in line to play a game on your home console where you are playing with millions of other people on their home console over this magical thing called the internet.

I am playing with one other person, not millions.

locked

1603 views

It's perfectly justified. Travel back in time to 1985 and tell someone you have to wait in line to play a game on your home console where you are playing with millions of other people on their home console over this magical thing called the internet.

I am playing with one other person, not millions.

Weird, you spawn into an empty instance of every public space?

locked

1537 views

It doesn't have to be an either/or proposition. You know how you fix it? Let us play the goddamn game offline.

locked

1548 views

It doesn't have to be an either/or proposition. You know how you fix it? Let us play the goddamn game offline.

It needs critical mass to support public events, strike matchmaking, and the general atmosphere of seeing other guardians in public spaces whether that's the tower or out on Patrol while you're playing through the story.

If a significant portion of players were playing offline, it would affect that. By how much and to what extent is definitely debatable, but I believe that at that point, it would no longer be Destiny. It'd be some barren single player game that you could sometimes play co-op with.

locked

1546 views

You can buy the game the next day and still get home before the servers are up, but you'll have missed the rage-inducing failure of the company to adequately plan for the massive influx of new logins.

This is also another reason why staggered launches are easier to manage than releasing something to the entire world all at once.

Some of the reactions in this thread are more rage-inducing to me than any failure on Bungie's part.

It's perfectly justified. Travel back in time to 1985 and tell someone you have to wait in line to play a game on your home console. They would laugh and call you crazy.

Because it is crazy, and people who are okay with it are bad people and not helping.

I didn't say people should be okay with it. There's plenty of good people who were frustrated, I'm sure. The very best people, though, the most helpful people are those who rushed to the internet to post snark.

You want to hear some crazy stuff about 1985? No stores selling games were open at 5 am and if they were, you'd still have to drive back home. When you did, maybe your game didn't work. Without Twitter all you could do (after you tried blowing on the cartridge of course) was call your buddy down the street to see if his copy worked. You then drove back to the store and they told you to take it up with Nintendo. You mailed it back on your dime. Six to eight weeks later you got a replacement.

One good thing about 1985: it was much easier to avoid others' whining, cynicism, sarcasm, and self-righteousness.

Personal note: I didn't plan to but I woke up at 5 a.m. to the alert on my Xbox that ROI was now available. I also was disappointed that the servers were down. Got back on around 7:30 am and everything was fine. A tiny blip as far as my Destiny experience goes. People are excited to play, and I can understand their frustration. I felt that, too, and I also felt some compassion for the IT people at Bungie, and hoped that this wasn't a DNS attack or some major hardware failure that couldn't be foreseen. I could do armchair quarterbacking, but I know nothing about it and I think it's presumptive to assume this was some kind of failure of planning on Bungie's part. You can't plan for everything. Individuals make mistakes. Shit happens. Also: these are game servers we're talking about here, not life support systems.

locked

1541 views

Also: these are game servers we're talking about here, not life support systems.

To be fair, Destiny is Cody's life support system. Even back when he quit the game forever once and for all, he wouldn't shut up about it, so you can understand his frustration with not being able to instantly feed his obsession.

Back in 1985, you did have to stand in a line to buy your game (assuming they had enough copies available by the time you got to the front). Heck, in 2004, I had to stand in an hour-long line after the game launched to pick up Halo 2. I wasn't able to hop on at the stroke of 12 to play, so Cody's entitled whining is really dumb and blind to the reality of things (uncharacteristic!).

Besides, we don't know for certain what caused the downtime, but it wasn't a big deal in the grand scheme of things. Not gonna use that as a strike against Bungie or anything. Heck, I might buy some Silver later today...

locked

1528 views

Also: these are game servers we're talking about here, not life support systems.

To be fair, Destiny is Cody's life support system. Even back when he quit the game forever once and for all, he wouldn't shut up about it, so you can understand his frustration with not being able to instantly feed his obsession.

Back in 1985, you did have to stand in a line to buy your game (assuming they had enough copies available by the time you got to the front). Heck, in 2004, I had to stand in an hour-long line after the game launched to pick up Halo 2. I wasn't able to hop on at the stroke of 12 to play, so Cody's entitled whining is really dumb and blind to the reality of things (uncharacteristic!).

Besides, we don't know for certain what caused the downtime, but it wasn't a big deal in the grand scheme of things. Not gonna use that as a strike against Bungie or anything. Heck, I might buy some Silver later today...

You evil person you.[does challenge dance]

locked

1527 views

I don't get it. Bungie should know the exact number of people who pre-ordered the game. That means they should know exactly the capacity required. Right?

Unless a large amount of people like me bought the game at 1:50am, but I doubt it. Seems like they should have been able to predict capacity very accurately.

locked

1602 views

Whatever happened wasn't a capacity issue, The entire login system across the game, website, and app was completely down. The queue is probably probably just to prevent all million of us from trying to login at the same time once the actual issue is fixed.

locked

1600 views

Whatever happened wasn't a capacity issue, The entire login system across the game, website, and app was completely down. The queue is probably probably just to prevent all million of us from trying to login at the same time once the actual issue is fixed.

Login issues at launch are like, a huge issue for online games. It should be priority 1 to eliminate them. They can be foreseen. I don't care what the problem is. Short of a denial of service attack there is no excuse whatsoever in 2016 to not be able to log into your game.

locked

1589 views

Agreed. And Destiny has done pretty well with all its other launches, attacks not withstanding. I never had a problem with the beta or any other launch I don't think. Clearly someone screwed something up here. I just don't think it was a capacity issue like we've seen with a ton of other games in the past.

locked

1587 views

- No text -

locked

1570 views

It didn't look like an overload of logins, like most day 1 server issues are. The entire system crashed, even on parts that wouldn't normally crash. I think they introduced the queue because something very wrong happened and instantly allowing everyone to login at once as the problem is being fixed would be physically impossible.

locked

1574 views

Yeah, for a while I'd get knocked out of the queue and would be several thousands spots farther back than I was. Eventually, around 5:45, I stopped getting kicked out and the numbers started dropping but first hundreds every minute, then thousands, then near the top of the hour it was dropping by 20,000 at a time until I got down to something in the 540 range and a minute later I was in.

The queue probably helped prevent an unintentional DOS by us players, but I think the original problem was basically unrelated to the number of people trying to get in.

locked

1566 views

And for at least an hour it appeared nobody could log in to any section of Bungie's systems with their Xbox or PlayStation accounts. Not the game. Not the website. Not the forums. Not the companion apps. I was getting Webmaster authentication errors for quite a while just trying to post to the help forums.

At some point it goes from being a capacity issue, as in not enough servers or bandwidth or whatever, to a "it's just plain broken" issue. I think it started as the latter and then as things were getting back up to speed shifted to the former.

locked

1578 views

At some point it goes from being a capacity issue, as in not enough servers or bandwidth or whatever, to a "it's just plain broken" issue.

Um....no. Just no.

You make IT me angry lol.

"Just plain broken" is not a good description.

This looks like a case of higher than expected demand. It happens.

Having said that, I don't work for Bungie or support their network so I can only speculate, but I promise you it's not as easy as you think it is to solve those types of outages.

locked

1599 views

I don't get it. Bungie should know the exact number of people who pre-ordered the game. That means they should know exactly the capacity required. Right?

Unless a large amount of people like me bought the game at 1:50am, but I doubt it. Seems like they should have been able to predict capacity very accurately.

I know I've been on Reddit too much of late because I immediately looked for a way to give this some upvotes.

I wonder if we couldn't make a small fortune by leasing temporary login server time to video game companies who insist on foolishly rolling out their games simultaneously across the world rather than in a staggered fashion to reduce server strain. All they need to do is rent some server time from Amazon AWS or something for like a week.

Game companies are constantly saying things like "we sold 10 million copies so we will need to be able to have enough servers for 4 million concurrent players" totally ignoring the fact that at least 5 million of the players will all be logging on at the same damn time on launch day.

Another way to fix this issue is to stealth release it. Open up RoI 12 hours earlier and you give everyone the opportunity to log in as soon as they find out it's up, but that would naturally result in a staggering of login attempts rather than all of the attempts happening at once.

Lastly, MMOs of all stripes should have public test realms. HOLY SHIT WHY DOESN'T DESTINY HAVE THESE? Find and fix the problems before the game launches. There aren't enough testers in the state of washington to properly test an MMO-type game let alone enough at Bungie.

locked

1546 views

I pre-ordered the game. I got the preorder bonuses. I slept I woke up and I missed all of the server downtime. I'm not really sure what this has to do with pre-ordering.

locked

1564 views

Anyone who bought, downloaded and tried to play the game at launch time was affected; not just people who pre-ordered.

locked

1562 views

- No text -

locked

1579 views

- No text -

locked

1580 views

- No text -

locked

1610 views

No queue. I'm strongly considering blocking his phone number.

locked

1665 views

Xbox queue is up to 311,638... is the PS queue something close to that?

locked

1633 views

- No text -

locked

1626 views

No queue. I'm strongly considering blocking his phone number.

I would do that in a heartbeat. How did he manage to lag his way in? Thats not how this is supposed to work

locked

1637 views

- No text -

locked

1618 views

'Earth - Story'

Everyone else reads as 'Destiny'.

locked

1630 views

https://imgur.com/qw8vNOW

locked

1686 views

- No text -

locked

1567 views

- No text -

locked

1582 views

- No text -

locked

1601 views

Never even saw the queue screen.

locked

1591 views

Probably hundreds of streamers streaming the queue*. Best community? Best community.

*Granted, a few dozen have already gotten in.

locked

1647 views

[ ] Logged in during RoI Launch

locked

1647 views

- No text -

locked

1617 views

- No text -

locked

1552 views

- No text -

locked

1553 views

- No text -

locked

1551 views

[ ] Logged in during RoI Launch

Um, not possible.

locked

1537 views

- No text -

locked

1531 views

Number 321252 in a queue.

Why do I have to wait in line to play a game I bought?

#waitingwithfriends

locked

1638 views

I just got kicked out of the queue.

What the fuck is the point of a line if you can't stay in it?

locked

1586 views

Number 321252 in a queue.

Why do I have to wait in line to play a game I bought?

#waitingwithfriends

It's completely worth it to know that you're unhappy, and likely still sitting in front of the screen. :v

If you're not able to get on by 7pm est. Sammy and I do need a third, I wanna hear all about the indignity...

locked

1575 views

Can't use the gear manager, so I have to use the vault like a savage.

#weareconstantlyimprovingthegame

locked

1601 views

- No text -

locked

1569 views

- No text -

locked

1591 views

I believe you meant #HappyDestinyDownDay

locked

1561 views

- No text -

locked

1545 views

- No text -

locked

1565 views

- No text -

locked

1543 views

So...three Sterling packages per account?

locked

1570 views

Back to the forum index

RSS Feed of thread

DBO Forums

Servers Unavailable (Destiny)