data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/46311/46311a0bd571fe0fa6abe9db18b8ab04e36a9c7f" alt="Avatar"
Is it? (Off-Topic)
I would argue that the symbolic act is for the person/people participating in the ritual. At that point, you could make the argument that the sacrifice of the beer has an effect on the participant, but I'm not sure you can say it will have any impact on those who inspired the ritual. It really depends upon the goal of the ritual. Will drinking that beer again in the future conjure up the memory of comrades who have moved on? Then drinking it will help make those flavors and smells (which are powerful for memory) solidify the experience. However, sometimes it is helpful when one sacrifices something they love to honor the memory of someone. The act of self-denial shows the value of that person and you will remember that time unoudid denied you beer forever, thus enforcing the esteem placed upon that relationship. It really depends on the participant and the goal.
I say drink it, and tell unoudid that you poured it out.
Complete thread:
- I probably won't be around quite as much -
Blackt1g3r,
2017-02-06, 17:40
- I probably won't be around quite as much - ChrisTheeCrappy, 2017-02-06, 18:00
- I probably won't be around quite as much -
unoudid,
2017-02-06, 18:08
- I probably won't be around quite as much - Blackt1g3r, 2017-02-06, 21:14
- I probably won't be around quite as much - Kermit, 2017-02-06, 19:36
- I probably won't be around quite as much - ZackDark, 2017-02-06, 20:29
- I probably won't be around quite as much - Robot Chickens, 2017-02-06, 22:35
- Yes, good reasons
- Blackt1g3r, 2017-02-07, 02:02
- When? -
Up North 65,
2017-02-07, 12:07
- When? -
unoudid,
2017-02-07, 13:09
- When? -
Blackt1g3r,
2017-02-07, 19:28
- I try not to waste beer.
- Up North 65, 2017-02-08, 16:52
- so our memory would be a waste?
- unoudid, 2017-02-08, 17:02
- Drink the beer in your memory. All problems solved
- Robot Chickens, 2017-02-08, 17:08
- Stop being selfish. pouring one out is for them, not you.
- unoudid, 2017-02-08, 17:49
- Wait you "pour one out"? -
ZackDark,
2017-02-08, 18:33
- you need some fallen friends - unoudid, 2017-02-08, 19:08
- Is it? -
Robot Chickens,
2017-02-08, 19:07
- You Sir are a bad person -
unoudid,
2017-02-08, 20:30
- You Sir are a bad person - Claude Errera, 2017-02-08, 20:35
- +1
- Robot Chickens, 2017-02-08, 21:50
- Is it? -
ZackDark,
2017-02-09, 13:18
- Maybe this will help? - unoudid, 2017-02-09, 17:23
- You Sir are a bad person -
unoudid,
2017-02-08, 20:30
- Need better alcoholics. Spilled beer gets you punched.
- ProbablyLast, 2017-02-09, 22:48
- Wait you "pour one out"? -
ZackDark,
2017-02-08, 18:33
- Stop being selfish. pouring one out is for them, not you.
- Drink the beer in your memory. All problems solved
- so our memory would be a waste?
- I try not to waste beer.
- When? -
Blackt1g3r,
2017-02-07, 19:28
- When? - Blackt1g3r, 2017-02-09, 17:23
- When? -
unoudid,
2017-02-07, 13:09
- When? -
Up North 65,
2017-02-07, 12:07