Make decisions for HP (Gaming)
Hi everyone. Help me out?
I'm thinking of actually playing video games again. I heard that some new consoles were coming out.
Which should I choose? XBone or PS4?
I have no idea about anything ever.
State your cases!
Make decisions for HP
Reasons I'm buying an Xbox One:
- Titanfall
- Halo 5
- Kinect + new UI = Awesome TV integration.
The PS4 might have slightly better graphics, but I'm more interested in the XBO's ability to snap a Skype video chat onto the side of my screen while I'm playing games or watching TV. I might miss out on some exclusive Destiny content (or maybe just timed-exclusive), but I'll deal with it.
Make decisions for HP *56K warning*
Heads up, I'm about to burn through one or two years worth of DBO GAF tolerance.
Price:
Xbox One: $500
PS4: $400
Announced Exclusives (might not be 100% up-to-date):
Internet Multiplat Console War Outrage:
Calladooty:
Xbox One: 720p
PS4: 1080p
Battlefield 4:
Xbox One: 720p
PS4: 900p
Not that you need to worry about lower native resolutions, though. I'll let Chief of Staff for Devices and Studios Group at Microsoft Aaron Greenberg explain why it doesn't matter:
Obligatory Resogun gif:
In Conclusion:
Make decisions for HP
I'm getting both, but I plan on the Xbox One being my main system. I think the interface is cleaner, the exclusives are better, and I already have a very good network of XBL friends. Now, the resolution thing I doubt will even be different in 3-6 months.
Wow...No Kidding.
- No text -
Make decisions for HP
My silly TV only does 720p so I have no real interest in who can output what. I think my reasons for (probably, eventually) going for a Xbone are similar to yours. With an Xbone I get both Destiny and Halo, plus a provenish UI double plus an actually proven online service. All in 2015 or so based on my current plans...
Make decisions for HP
Hi everyone. Help me out?
I'm thinking of actually playing video games again. I heard that some new consoles were coming out.
Which should I choose? XBone or PS4?
I have no idea about anything ever.
State your cases!
I was wondering why you were never on.
I'm going to give you the best answer (obviously)... Do Nothing. You will get the best results in the long run, if you can wait... it doesn't have to be long.
Its the Holiday season and everyone loves a new console smell, but its a lie. After the first influx of users, and the results of said influx are known - then would it be a good time to choose. 2014 is just around the corner.
But now? Ha. If you must . . . Flip a Coin.
Make decisions for HP
My silly TV only does 720p so I have no real interest in who can output what.
Image rendered natively at 240p:
240p image downsampled from a much higher resolution:
Not only does the lower image look cleaner when still, you'll get far less pixel crawling from motion. Having a 720p TV will put some limits on the raw sharpness of your image, but you'll still get huge benefits from higher-resolution native rendering. Downsampling is glorious, and part of why I was totally okay with Reach when I only had an SD CRT on hand. In some ways I appreciated its visuals on that TV more than on my HDTV. It wasn't as sharp, but pixel-for-pixel the 360's output seemed much cleaner in SD.
tl;dr 1080p games will look better on your 720p TV than 720p games, all other things being equal.
^ What he said
To add onto the resolution issue, I doubt it's anything more than new generation jitters that will get straightened out eventually as time goes on.
As for me though? I'd also suggest getting an XBO. To put it simply they've shown me things that I want to see in a console and I trust their software and hardware more than I would Playstation. But I also don't plan on getting it on release day. Since Black Friday is soo close already, I think it'd be better to just wait and see what the deals are going to be.
OT: Xenos, do you plan on upgrading your copy of BF4 to the one version? I was wondering since I'm going to need someone to play with when I get my copy because I honestly have never touched a BF game outside of the recent 'beta' and I need someone to carry me for a little bit :p
^ What he said
OT: Xenos, do you plan on upgrading your copy of BF4 to the one version? I was wondering since I'm going to need someone to play with when I get my copy because I honestly have never touched a BF game outside of the recent 'beta' and I need someone to carry me for a little bit :p
Yeah I plan on getting the One version. I still haven't decided if I'll upgrade my current version or not though for a couple of reasons: I have a few friends who have no current plans to get the One, and two I kind of want to keep my Next Gen experience all digital.
Make decisions for HP
Hi everyone. Help me out?
I'm thinking of actually playing video games again. I heard that some new consoles were coming out.
Which should I choose? XBone or PS4?
PS4. Better technically, cheaper, and you'll get Quantic Dream's next game.
^ What he said
All digital? That's not such a bad idea, especially with how easy it'll be to switch between things on the XBO. I'll have to see what the prices are when the time comes, but either way, I'll be there, and it will be exciting.
Make decisions for HP
tl;dr 1080p games will look better on your 720p TV than 720p games, all other things being equal.
But this kind of comparison only really works when you look up close. They might not be 100% the same, and one may be slightly better, but they'll always be close enough that it makes no substantial difference to whether or not you enjoy the game. When you're sat 12-15 feet away this kind of detail almost disappears. The bigger difference is something like frame rate, but apparently neither company is intent on insisting on 60 Hz refresh rates.
^ What he said
Eh, be careful with that all digital experience. Some random company may later decide that the game you bought isn't really yours anymore, for example.
Make decisions for HP
When you're sat 12-15 feet away this kind of detail almost disappears.
There'll still be a difference with shimmering on very thin details, but sure, on TVs of reasonable sizes there won't be a significant sharpness difference at that point.
That's a questionable justification, though. Most people don't sit 12-15 feet from their TVs when gaming. 7-10 feet was pretty common with SD CRTs, and from what I've been able to tell perusing internet threads, HDTVs actually reduced that distance for most people (my guess is that it's at least partly because LCDs don't give off weird moire patterns when you sit too close). Regardless of image quality, people just want to sit closer. More often than not I read about people sitting like 6' from a 50".
But sure, sitting farther from your TV, taking your glasses off, blindfolding yourself... there are plenty of ways to make the difference go away!
Make decisions for HP
That's a questionable justification, though. Most people don't sit 12-15 feet from their TVs when gaming. 7-10 feet was pretty common with SD CRTs, and from what I've been able to tell perusing internet threads, HDTVs actually reduced that distance for most people (my guess is that it's at least partly because LCDs don't give off weird moire patterns when you sit too close). Regardless of image quality, people just want to sit closer. More often than not I read about people sitting like 6' from a 50".
Sounds mostly anecdotal to me. From my own personal anecdotal evidence most people sit on a couch while playing video games which is at least 10' away from their TV. Personally I set about 12' from a 60" TV and while I can tell a difference between 720p and 1080p it's not such a big difference that I feel slighted with 720p. In fact all my blu-ray rips are ripped at 720p because the better quality isn't worth the extra HDD space in my opinion.
So I guess this all comes down to: do you care about having the absolutely best resolution immediately upon release? Then get a PS4. If you don't care, decide based on games or community.
Make decisions for HP
So I guess this all comes down to: do you care about having the absolutely best resolution immediately upon release? Then get a PC.
Fixed. :P
Make decisions for HP
So I guess this all comes down to: do you care about having the absolutely best resolution immediately upon release? Then get a PC.
Fixed. :P
Haha, thanks Duncan. Someone had to speak up for the "Master Race" at some point.
Make decisions for HP
Well, I was going to early adopt one of the two systems because I wanted to play games like Watch Dogs and especially Destiny (yeah, they're cross-gen; I still want to play the best version, though), and the week of E3 I had made my choice. I'm getting a PS4 first, for several reasons:
1) Price. At $400, The PS4 costs $100 less than the XBO. $100 that can be spent on other things, like, say, a couple of games. For someone like me who doesn't have a ton of disposable income, $100 is a lot, and it takes me months to save up/pay off a big purchase like a game console. The XBO costs $100 more because of Kinect, plain and simple, and I have no interest in the device.
2) Online Services. While PSN used to be a joke, PS+ is now considered by many to be at least as good if not better than XBL Gold. As an added bonus, should I ever decide that I'm done with online gaming period, or my subscription lapses because I don't have the money to renew it, I can still use all my PS4's functions sans online play (and even then some games won't require PS+) and the Instant Game Collection. Meanwhile, MS is still locking nearly everything behind the Gold pay wall. It's easier to list the things you don't need Gold for than the things you do need it for. Basically, you can listen to CDs, watch disc-based movies, and play single-player games, things I was able to do with my PS2 more than a decade ago.
3) Games. While both systems are on par for launch window exclusives being released to retail, in the long term Sony has the advantage. MS's refusal to invest more heavily on in-house development means that the only first-party studios they have that are working on major AAA exclusives are 343I, Turn10, Lionhead, and a new group called Black Tusk, with Remedy being a de facto second party. Meanwhile, Sony has Naughty Dog, Guerrilla, Polyphony Digital, Sucker Punch, Evolution Studios, Media Molecule, SCE Santa Monica, and SCE Japan Studio, as well as second parties like Quantic Dream and Ready At Dawn. If history repeats itself, the XBO might do well in the short term as MS invests in buying exclusivity rights for various games from third-party publishers, but after the first 3 years or so, they'll eventually be whittled down to Halo, Forza, Fable, and maybe one or two other games, while the PS4 will still be getting a solid stream of exclusives, most of which will be first party.
Of course, that's just retail exclusives. The PS4 is getting a huge flood of indie and other downloadable games, including Resogun, Rime, Octodad: Dadliest Catch, The Witness, and, well, everything else in this list here.
More personally, the PS4's exclusives just appeal to me more, not to mention they have a proven track record. I have no interest in Ryse, Dead Rising 3, and Forza (hack & slash games and sim racers aren't my bag), Titanfall did interest for a bit, then it was revealed that it had no single-player campaign. I was never a huge Killer Instinct fan (I liked MK the most back in the day), either. Black Tusk is a new studio and therefore they're unproven, not to mention we still know squat about what they're working on. That leaves Halo. I still like Halo, though my interest has waned a bit after Halo 4. The promise of Halo 3 immediately sold me on a 360, but 343I's efforts on Halo 4 means the promise of Halo 5 isn't enough by itself to sell me on the XBO. Even if 343I is able to reinvigorate my interest in the series and Halo 5 ends up being the best Halo ever, I'm not paying $500 for a system that'll end up being mostly another "Halo Box."
So, it was pay $400 for a system that'll have Killzone, Infamous, Knack, DriveClub (more arcade-y than Forza), and whatever ND, MM, and the rest are working on, as well as a huge selection of indie games as well as exclusive content for Destiny, or pay $500 for a system whose first interesting exclusive isn't due until next fall. The choice was easy to make: PlayStation 4. Once the price goes down to around $350 or less, I'll get an XBO, but as of right now, the combination of games, price, and other small bits of miscellany make it an unappealing choice as of the present date. Meanwhile, Sony has hit all the right notes throughout the year.
So, as for you, HP, what matters to you? Is price important? Do you like indies? Are system specs a big deal? Do Sony's exclusives appeal to you more than MS's? Then get a PS4. If money is no object and you don't mind paying $100 more for Kinect, if you like MS's exclusives better, if you think Kinect is the most awesometacular must-have accessory ever, and if specs and indie games aren't important to you, then get an XBO.
Make decisions for HP
That's a questionable justification, though. Most people don't sit 12-15 feet from their TVs when gaming.
[citation needed]
Make decisions for HP
So I guess this all comes down to: do you care about having the absolutely best resolution immediately upon release? Then get a PC.
Fixed. :P
How's that PC version of Destiny coming along?
Make decisions for HP
Honestly, I'm perfectly content playing the few indie games I do on the PC. Granted my XBO is going to rarely be used for games as I don't have tons of time for them. It's worth the investment for me, though, for its other features.
Heh.
Dadliest Catch.
I know some premenopausal women who are desperate to find that guy.
Make decisions for HP
If you have to get one, the PS4.
$100 cheaper, better hardware, (currently) better performing 3rd party games, far better indie support, already better selling in the US [via pre-order numbers], practically guaranteed to do better in Europe & Asia [therefore bigger market share and therefore more dev support] and more.
The exclusive retail launch line-up is weaker on PS4.
This list of games from IGN for the new few months might help you:
Make decisions for HP
Actually, I don't know if it's up your alleyway, but the 12 months "free" of Xbox Fitness does look pretty cool. :
PC
I say spend 800 dollars to build a nice little PC. It's a bit more, but you save money on games, save money on no live, you get more variety, mods, better hardware etc.
PC
I say spend 800 dollars to build a nice little PC. It's a bit more, but you save money on games, save money on no live, you get more variety, mods, better hardware etc.
I definitely agree that having a gaming PC is worth the money if you have it, but it's kind of funny on this forum since Bungie has pretty much said don't plan on Destiny for PC anytime soon :)
But yeah, if you have the money, aren't worried about Destiny any time soon or Halo 5, I would definitely recommend a PC. More games, upgradable and great deal on games for PC.
On the other side I've kind of abandoned PC gaming for the most part because I would rather just not worry about hardware concerns and like having matchmaking like on XBL. Love mouse and keyboard but I hate the matchmaking most games put into their PC versions.
PC
I have a small, minuscule hope, that Bungie will announce Destiny for Steambox. :)
PC
A friend convinced me to buy a PC game a while back. I remember doing the tutorial, great, ok, then it was time to hop into multiplayer. "Choose your server," it said. There was a list of ~1000 games going on. "I have to choose??? The game is supposed to do that for me while I refill my drink!" Back to XBL I went.
Heh
Yeah, this is pretty much the most annoying part of BF3 for me
Make decisions for HP
[citation needed]
Well, I was probably being hyperbolic by suggesting that a substantial number of people with 50" screens game at 6' or less.
However...
Not sure about any terribly scientific studies, but conversations around the internet seem to suggest that 12' is quite on the high side. For instance, here's a thread I saw a year ago on GAF regarding the subject. Not a huge sample size, but if you compile all the responses that people offered regarding actual television sets, it looks like this (I took the middle of the range for people who gave a range over which they sit):
And the person at 12 feet? That was the OP, who was saying that it felt awkward to sit so far from the TV.
Other places on NeoGAF seem to give similar results. There are annual threads where people post images of their setups... a lot of the posts don't give a very complete picture of the rooms, but of those that do, far less than half the posts demonstrate what looks like a TV viewing distance of more than 12'. And of the ones that even let you sit that far back given the furniture placement, some look like the sort of setup where you'd sit on the edge of the couch (and thus actually game at ~10').
My own experiences tend to agree with the NeoGAF's visible distribution. I usually game at 6'-10' on a 37" screen depending on how I feel and what I'm playing. And of my friends whose viewing distances I can recall off the top of my head, most sit in the ballpark of 6'-8' from their HDTVs.
I suppose it's entirely possible that I'm wrong, and that the various populations I've sampled from have all been skewed in the same direction, or that my sample sets are too small, etc... but I'd be extremely suprised if I was wrong about the basic claim that most console gamers play at <12'.
Xenos:
Personally I set about 12' from a 60" TV and while I can tell a difference between 720p and 1080p it's not such a big difference that I feel slighted with 720p. In fact all my blu-ray rips are ripped at 720p because the better quality isn't worth the extra HDD space in my opinion.
If we assume that distance/(screen diagonal) is a more reasonable basis than raw viewing distance (which it is to an extent), you're not an outlier. You do have an above-average TV diagonal, however. The same ratio would put me 7.4' from my TV, which is on the lower half of the distances I use.
Your blu-ray example sucks, though. The real world has a lot of photons flying about, and the result is that live-action footage has nearly perfect supersample antialiasing. Ditto for CGI; it doesn't have to render in real-time. So even if the video is encoded at 1080p, it might have been rendered at some cartoonishly high resolution like 15360x8640.
This is why I brought up the importance of supersampling in the low-resolution TV discussion. Even if higher resolutions won't make the images much sharper on a 720 TV (or when playing on a 1080p TV from a large viewing distance), it will make them more stable. When you compare a 720p encoding of a film versus a 1080p encoding of a film, your only limitation is the raw crispness/sharpness. The discrepency in raw crispness/sharpness is going to become less prominant very quickly with distance. Even 480p DVDs, relatively blurry and poor in colour quality, manage to avoid aliasing. Yet at 720p, thin geometric details and tron lines in Halo 4 alias and shimmer like crazy.
And that sort of shimmering isn't something that disappears at a low distance. One day I decided to try and see if it were possible to sit far enough from the TV that Halo 3's specular aliasing wasn't obvious. Soon enough I hit the back wall of my house, fifty-three feet away. The game was unplayably hard to make out at that distance, but I could still see those artifacty thin highlights crawling and shimmering just fine. Higher resolutions help to mitigate that sort of thing.
I would argue that conflating a given resolution in film encoding with a native game resolution is a common form of unintentional (or sometimes intentional, if you're deliberately misleading people) equivocation.
Make decisions for HP
Hi everyone. Help me out?
I'm thinking of actually playing video games again. I heard that some new consoles were coming out.
Which should I choose? XBone or PS4?
I have no idea about anything ever.
State your cases!
I was wondering why you were never on.I'm going to give you the best answer (obviously)... Do Nothing. You will get the best results in the long run, if you can wait... it doesn't have to be long.
Its the Holiday season and everyone loves a new console smell, but its a lie. After the first influx of users, and the results of said influx are known - then would it be a good time to choose. 2014 is just around the corner.
But now? Ha. If you must . . . Flip a Coin.
This guy knows what's up.
I think I'll wait until the hurly burly is done, and the battle is lost and won.
Make decisions for HP
Let's see.
- Price isn't an issue.
- Kinect is not something I care about in the slightest.
- I don't know enough or care that much about exclusives for either console.
- Indie games don't matter either
- The functionality of PSN without a subscription, albeit limited, is somewhat appealing
Result? Pretty inconclusive. Thanks for the great job of laying this out for me, though.
As a side note, I really liked being able to stream content from my computers to my 360. Do any of the upcoming consoles do that? I thought I heard some rumblings about that kind of support getting cut back.
Well, I was going to early adopt one of the two systems because I wanted to play games like Watch Dogs and especially Destiny (yeah, they're cross-gen; I still want to play the best version, though), and the week of E3 I had made my choice. I'm getting a PS4 first, for several reasons:
1) Price. At $400, The PS4 costs $100 less than the XBO. $100 that can be spent on other things, like, say, a couple of games. For someone like me who doesn't have a ton of disposable income, $100 is a lot, and it takes me months to save up/pay off a big purchase like a game console. The XBO costs $100 more because of Kinect, plain and simple, and I have no interest in the device.
2) Online Services. While PSN used to be a joke, PS+ is now considered by many to be at least as good if not better than XBL Gold. As an added bonus, should I ever decide that I'm done with online gaming period, or my subscription lapses because I don't have the money to renew it, I can still use all my PS4's functions sans online play (and even then some games won't require PS+) and the Instant Game Collection. Meanwhile, MS is still locking nearly everything behind the Gold pay wall. It's easier to list the things you don't need Gold for than the things you do need it for. Basically, you can listen to CDs, watch disc-based movies, and play single-player games, things I was able to do with my PS2 more than a decade ago.
3) Games. While both systems are on par for launch window exclusives being released to retail, in the long term Sony has the advantage. MS's refusal to invest more heavily on in-house development means that the only first-party studios they have that are working on major AAA exclusives are 343I, Turn10, Lionhead, and a new group called Black Tusk, with Remedy being a de facto second party. Meanwhile, Sony has Naughty Dog, Guerrilla, Polyphony Digital, Sucker Punch, Evolution Studios, Media Molecule, SCE Santa Monica, and SCE Japan Studio, as well as second parties like Quantic Dream and Ready At Dawn. If history repeats itself, the XBO might do well in the short term as MS invests in buying exclusivity rights for various games from third-party publishers, but after the first 3 years or so, they'll eventually be whittled down to Halo, Forza, Fable, and maybe one or two other games, while the PS4 will still be getting a solid stream of exclusives, most of which will be first party.
Of course, that's just retail exclusives. The PS4 is getting a huge flood of indie and other downloadable games, including Resogun, Rime, Octodad: Dadliest Catch, The Witness, and, well, everything else in this list here.
More personally, the PS4's exclusives just appeal to me more, not to mention they have a proven track record. I have no interest in Ryse, Dead Rising 3, and Forza (hack & slash games and sim racers aren't my bag), Titanfall did interest for a bit, then it was revealed that it had no single-player campaign. I was never a huge Killer Instinct fan (I liked MK the most back in the day), either. Black Tusk is a new studio and therefore they're unproven, not to mention we still know squat about what they're working on. That leaves Halo. I still like Halo, though my interest has waned a bit after Halo 4. The promise of Halo 3 immediately sold me on a 360, but 343I's efforts on Halo 4 means the promise of Halo 5 isn't enough by itself to sell me on the XBO. Even if 343I is able to reinvigorate my interest in the series and Halo 5 ends up being the best Halo ever, I'm not paying $500 for a system that'll end up being mostly another "Halo Box."
So, it was pay $400 for a system that'll have Killzone, Infamous, Knack, DriveClub (more arcade-y than Forza), and whatever ND, MM, and the rest are working on, as well as a huge selection of indie games as well as exclusive content for Destiny, or pay $500 for a system whose first interesting exclusive isn't due until next fall. The choice was easy to make: PlayStation 4. Once the price goes down to around $350 or less, I'll get an XBO, but as of right now, the combination of games, price, and other small bits of miscellany make it an unappealing choice as of the present date. Meanwhile, Sony has hit all the right notes throughout the year.
So, as for you, HP, what matters to you? Is price important? Do you like indies? Are system specs a big deal? Do Sony's exclusives appeal to you more than MS's? Then get a PS4. If money is no object and you don't mind paying $100 more for Kinect, if you like MS's exclusives better, if you think Kinect is the most awesometacular must-have accessory ever, and if specs and indie games aren't important to you, then get an XBO.
PC
I say spend 800 dollars to build a nice little PC. It's a bit more, but you save money on games, save money on no live, you get more variety, mods, better hardware etc.
You're talkin' to a PC gamer who is into "esports" and "progaming" so I'm good on that front.
Console gaming is more for the "kick back with the bros and shoot some things" games. I'd say the word casual, but I don't know what kind of mess that might kick up these days.
Make decisions for HP
Now that's more like a post I'd expect from you uberfoop :) I still don't think the difference will be so great that the (hopefully temporary) difference in resolution will be a huge deal, but I also think different people have different tolerances towards resolutions.
PC
Console gaming is more for the "kick back with the bros and shoot some things" games. I'd say the word casual, but I don't know what kind of mess that might kick up these days.
Caszh is the new hardcore dude.
PC
Duly noted :). I built my first gaming PC in about 10 years earlier this year and i've had zero interes in the next gen systems since then.
If you just want a couch box, definately the PS4 then. Cheaper, smarter design, better hardware, etc. The early games look better on the xbox 1, but honestly, both systems look to have pretty abysmal launch lineups.
Make decisions for HP
Let's see.
- Price isn't an issue.
- Kinect is not something I care about in the slightest.
- I don't know enough or care that much about exclusives for either console.
- Indie games don't matter either
- The functionality of PSN without a subscription, albeit limited, is somewhat appealing
Result? Pretty inconclusive. Thanks for the great job of laying this out for me, though.
As a side note, I really liked being able to stream content from my computers to my 360. Do any of the upcoming consoles do that? I thought I heard some rumblings about that kind of support getting cut back.
XBox One should be able to do all the same streaming the 360 can do (it supports DLNA) plus it can stream from SkyDrive if you really want it (cool, but really who uses SkyDrive?).
The PS4 for some reason dropped DLNA support.
As for the rest of your stuff, yeah pretty inconclusive.
Make decisions for HP *56K warning*
Tupo, where did you get that Captain America PS4 gif? That's pretty damn awesome.
PC
Heh, fair enough. Granted, a 360 / PS3 will play destiny till we get that sweet PC goodness. I'm okay waiting.
Make decisions for HP
Does the Xbox One still have Windows Media Center too?
Endure, they are the same and launch line ups are bland!
I am waiting for a good bundle or game lineup before I jump ship. And now all the fun Sony details are coming out, so the tried and true analogy stands.
Make decisions for HP
Does the Xbox One still have Windows Media Center too?
Sadly no, which I didn't realize until you asked. Apparently they replaced it with the fact that videos in your Videos folder and music in your Music folder will show up on your Xbox One or you can use the "Play to" feature that Windows 7 and Windows 8 has.
Make decisions for HP
Yuck. I guess I won't be able to get rid of my 360 from my entertainment center until I can build some other sort of WMC Extender. It's okay though, I wasn't really planning on getting an XOne anytime soon since it's so damn expensive.
You're proposing restraint?!? You're a madman!
- No text -
My heresy will stay my feet
- No text -
Make decisions for HP
Yuck. I guess I won't be able to get rid of my 360 from my entertainment center until I can build some other sort of WMC Extender. It's okay though, I wasn't really planning on getting an XOne anytime soon since it's so damn expensive.
My main computer is a Mac anyway, so I'll be using DLNA.
What he said
More personally, the PS4's exclusives just appeal to me more, not to mention they have a proven track record. I have no interest in Ryse, Dead Rising 3, and Forza (hack & slash games and sim racers aren't my bag), Titanfall did interest for a bit, then it was revealed that it had no single-player campaign. I was never a huge Killer Instinct fan (I liked MK the most back in the day), either. Black Tusk is a new studio and therefore they're unproven, not to mention we still know squat about what they're working on. That leaves Halo. I still like Halo, though my interest has waned a bit after Halo 4. The promise of Halo 3 immediately sold me on a 360, but 343I's efforts on Halo 4 means the promise of Halo 5 isn't enough by itself to sell me on the XBO. Even if 343I is able to reinvigorate my interest in the series and Halo 5 ends up being the best Halo ever, I'm not paying $500 for a system that'll end up being mostly another "Halo Box."
You summed up my own thinking. I had the same experience with Halo 3, buying my 360 solely on the promise of that single game, yet my interest in the franchise also has regrettably waned since Halo 4.
Get a Wii U
I don't have one but I've heard good things. :P