Why not use a newer forum style.

I was wondering why DBO doesn't have a forum like ABO, a phpBB style forum. Would it not be easier to follow?

locked

3775 views

I think most of us like it this way!

locked

3683 views

I think most of us like it this way!

Part of it, at least, is that a lot of people like the threaded titles that it normally displays. There may have also been technical reasons or what not, but I don't know about those.

locked

3705 views

I find this style much easier to follow, especially when separate discussions branch off in a thread.

locked

3665 views

Basically, this discussion

locked

3572 views

I had an answer for you, but it got caught in the spam filter.

Apparently linking to the HBO forum counts as spam, maybe? Either that or I accidentally words

locked

3650 views

Threads can branch naturally without people trying to get words in edgewise across multiple lines of discussion shoved into a single chain.

I've seen forums that use a "newer style" but want bungie.org-like levels of branchability, and they wind up with these weird discussions about whether it's appropriate to push certain groups of posts to certain new threads and places. It works, but it's a bit of a mess and takes more mod effort. Better to just cut out the middleman and use this format.

locked

3705 views

Yeah. Around HBO and now here you won't get those "you're posting in the wrong thread" or "we need to split / merge these threads" type situations. It does take a while to get used to though. I remember I lurked HBO's forums for a long time, back in the early 2000's, just trying to figure out how conversations worked in this structure.

I do like this one's ability to do a php-ish style display when you want it. I find myself using the normal view to pick off an odd reply here or there then switching to the "whole thread" view if a new big thread manages to crop up between visits.

locked

3695 views

It's the main reason I'm not much of a HaloGAF guy.

locked

3631 views

Agreed.

Not that they'd let me join anyway >_>

I agree with Blue. This style is easier to follow. The ONLY thing I don't care much for is the color scheme (just my preference. Everything else is pretty nifty!

locked

3705 views

I agree with Blue. This style is easier to follow. The ONLY thing I don't care much for is the color scheme (just my preference. Everything else is pretty nifty!

If I could make it a blue and silver color scheme I would be in hog heaven.

Well, it kinda is, but more so. And no more purple for the links. Purple is the worst color in the world. Besides orange.

locked

3607 views

Blue and Silver were my High School colors.

I like Purple.

Orange can go though, it acts like it own the place everywhere it goes.

locked

3626 views

Orange can go though, it acts like it own the place everywhere it goes.

Namely 'cause it does.

locked

3646 views

Orange is amazing. Disagree? PISTOLS AT DAWN.

locked

3551 views

Orange is amazing. Disagree? PISTOLS AT DAWN.

So be it. LET'S DO THIS.

locked

3533 views

Orange is amazing. Disagree? PISTOLS AT DAWN.

So be it. LET'S DO THIS.

Fellows! Let's settle this like civilized gentlemen.

Rocks at midnight.

locked

3569 views

Well, it kinda is, but more so. And no more purple for the links. Purple is the worst color in the world. Besides orange.

I miss not having the visited links immediately turn :visited. Sometimes I open multiple comments in multiple tabs and read through them. Returning to the main list, they're no longer highlighted visited without refreshing. *sadface*

locked

3593 views

locked

3621 views

locked

3597 views

Never mind. Even a refresh will display the bubble.

Ignore scarab, his dementia is kicking in.

locked

3594 views

My line of thought was that, had we the forum style the OP was suggesting, there would be no way to NM.

Am I wrong?

locked

3572 views

Does that make sense to you? :-)

I got all confused. Listen too much to me and so will you. I'm having a day, week, month...

locked

3633 views

Empty msg? This alert:

- No "message" tex't has been entered

locked

3584 views

Just to note, I've used the Firefox Stylish plugin to make a couple esthetic customizations for myself, so far... including:

body { font-family:arial,sans-serif!important; }
#content p, #content ul, #content td { line-height:1.2em!important; }
ul.thread { margin-bottom:0.2em!important; }
div.posting { padding:7px!important; background:white!important; }

- Dropped the Verdana. It's a wide font, and I like packing things in :)
- As above, reduced the spacing between lines of text
- Removing the spacing between threads (back similar to the HBO appearance)
- Popped the comment block out from the light blue background; sometimes it's hard to tell the comment text from the rest of the page

locked

3539 views

Thanks for the CSS. Every bit of help for the upcoming Forum Enhancer style (eta: next week) should help.

locked

3551 views

Thanks for the CSS. Every bit of help for the upcoming Forum Enhancer style (eta: next week) should help.

Well, thanks to Firefox's very easy development tools, locating and altering inline element styles is crazy simple. And being a web app developer has its benefits =P But anyone can learn css/html basics; makes life so much easier these days!

locked

3616 views

I'm glad we still have a threaded view ... I agree that's the way to go.

My only minor complaint or suggestion for improvement is that my fat almost-40 yr old fingers still struggle to hit the correct links when viewing the forums on a mobile device.

Any thoughts to an 'adaptive/responsive design or separate style' that is more fat finger touch friendly when viewed on a smaller screen or mobile device?

locked

3633 views

There's a little button next to the preview button for the first post of each thread. If you hit it you can see the entire thread with the replies indented. If you're looking at a post within a thread, you can open up the entire thread on one page by clicking the "Open in thread" button in the upper right corned. I've found these to be really helpful while reading on my phone. Otherwise I have the same problem of clicking links above and below the one I want to click.

locked

3615 views

Related: It used to be that most Android devices had a clickable trackball or trackpad, which was fantastic for hitting non-finger-friendly links on webpages - you could move the selection around between different links and then click on the one you actually wanted. Unfortunately, nothing in the last year or two has had that - it was phased out in favor of having as few buttons on the face as possible. :(

locked

3549 views

One of my favorite features of Chrome for Android is that if you hit a "link dense" part of a web page it will give you a little popup zoomed display so that you can hit the correct link.

locked

3543 views

Sounds great. I'll have to give it a try. I'm just so heavily invested in Firefox's sync for bookmarks/passwords and such now that I hardly ever touch Chrome. Sometimes I wish Chrome just sucked so it wouldn't be such a dilemma for me. :P

locked

3539 views

I'm the same way with Chrome's synching ability :)

I know mobile Firefox is awesome, but I'm so heavily invested in the Chrome/ChromeOS/Chrome for Android space that it's hard to break free!

locked

3534 views

I swapped over to chrome on my phone, but it's doing weird things with the links to the posts. They're all different sizes. Some are normal sized, but some are very tiny right below them. Others are big like I'm zoomed in on them. What's causing that?

locked

3551 views

It seems to happen to all replies on a thread starting 7 levels deep (heehee).

I tried both Chrome and Chrome Beta on both a phone and a tablet... all the same results. Not sure why it's happening, but it definitely seems like either the browser or the stylesheet is somehow shrinking the text to try and fit it all onscreen. If I rotate the tablet to landscape, the text increases in size, but is still noticeably smaller than the normal subject lines...

locked

3561 views

Chrome for iOS does this also. Very helpful

locked

3587 views

Any thoughts to an 'adaptive/responsive design or separate style' that is more fat finger touch friendly when viewed on a smaller screen or mobile device?

I wrote a user stylesheet for HBO's forum back in the day, which I still use — I'm sure it'd be possible to create something for DBO that had a go at improving the legibility / layout for touch devices via media queries etc. I'll have a play with that …oh I don't know, probably sometime in early 2014 but hey, I'll see what I can do :)

locked

3667 views

Yeah, I gotta say, the format is one of the main things keeping me from using the forum. It's a bummer, cause the people seem pretty cool. I understand yall not wanting to change things, though.

locked

3547 views

Back to the forum index

RSS Feed of thread

DBO Forums

Why not use a newer forum style.