Controversial Alternative (Destiny)
I'm going to suggest a controversial alternative to all the ones you suggested, though it combines parts of what you said.
I think a potentially fair, yet game changing load out is this:
Primary weapons stay exactly the same.
No Secondary slot, everyone has a sidearm equipped, acts as sidearms do now (including spawn with ammo).
Special and Heavy Weapons are combined. If a traditionally heavy weapon is equipped, ammo should drop as max 2 rockets, and one clip of an HMG. If a special weapon is equipped, 1.5x the normal ammo is dropped (Should be between 6-10 rounds ideally, perhaps 8-12 would be better). Heavy weapon ammo disappears on death, special cut in half. (We could certainly tweak this, just an idea).
Several things occur in this scenario:
1) Primary weapon choice is VERY important as this will be your primary engagement weapon. Probably why they named it such.
2) Personally, I love sidearms, I'm a bit biased here (I enjoy running a Scout Rifle, Sidearm loadout from time to time). That being said, sidearms are NOT one hit kills, but are intended for close quarters combat. They still require skill to kill your opponent. It's a pretty fair game when two people are sidearming each other. This gives you a weapon to use in CQB.
3) Heavy and Secondary become more precious (a goal of Bungie) and force the player to make a choice between what kind of weapon they want in this slot.
That's my suggestion. What say ye?
Complete thread:
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
CyberKN,
2016-04-26, 15:18
- Controversial Alternative -
BeardFade,
2016-04-26, 15:48
- Controversial Alternative - Kahzgul, 2016-04-26, 15:56
- Controversial Alternative -
dogcow,
2016-04-26, 15:57
- Controversial Alternative - BeardFade, 2016-04-26, 16:00
- Controversial Alternative -
slycrel,
2016-04-26, 17:30
- I agree, my suggestion was PvP biased - BeardFade, 2016-04-26, 17:44
- Controversial Alternative -
red robber,
2016-04-26, 21:21
- Controversial Alternative -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 21:28
- Controversial Alternative -
red robber,
2016-04-26, 21:40
- Huh? You're supporting his point with that... - ZackDark, 2016-04-26, 22:03
- Controversial Alternative -
red robber,
2016-04-26, 21:40
- Controversial Alternative -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 21:28
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
red robber,
2016-04-26, 21:35
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
stabbim,
2016-04-27, 14:07
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 14:11
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
BeardFade,
2016-04-27, 14:22
- Sounds interesting. I'll try it out once I level them up. - ZackDark, 2016-04-27, 15:06
- Sidearms are beastly in PvP -
WildthingVII,
2016-04-27, 16:31
- That was dirty -
unoudid,
2016-04-27, 18:04
- Also, that second guy can't hit jack -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 18:26
- Yes, I should have died... - WildthingVII, 2016-04-27, 20:01
- Also, that second guy can't hit jack -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 18:26
- That melee range is ridiculous. Gotta be 15-20 feet there. - BeardFade, 2016-04-27, 19:21
- Yes they are -
bluerunner,
2016-04-27, 19:32
- Yes they are - Xenos, 2016-04-29, 13:14
- Sidearms are beastly in PvP -
Argent_17,
2016-04-29, 11:52
- Sidearms are beastly in PvP - WildthingVII, 2016-04-29, 13:50
- That was dirty -
unoudid,
2016-04-27, 18:04
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
BeardFade,
2016-04-27, 14:22
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 14:11
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-27, 14:26
- Nah. Just let it drop. - Funkmon, 2016-04-27, 14:40
- Best Idea in 19 months. -
stabbim,
2016-04-27, 14:07
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 15:49
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
CyberKN,
2016-04-26, 15:53
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. - dogcow, 2016-04-26, 16:01
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. - Blackt1g3r, 2016-04-26, 16:24
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
CyberKN,
2016-04-26, 15:53
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
squidnh3,
2016-04-26, 15:51
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 15:52
- Auto-rifles would like a word with you. - CyberKN, 2016-04-26, 15:53
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 15:52
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Claude Errera,
2016-04-26, 15:53
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 16:07
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
ZackDark,
2016-04-26, 16:50
- Random ammo drops -
CyberKN,
2016-04-26, 17:03
- But now Specials are powerhouse power-weapons -
ZackDark,
2016-04-26, 17:30
- But now Specials are powerhouse power-weapons -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-26, 17:46
- I think we were discussing PvE there, but I agree - ZackDark, 2016-04-26, 19:12
- But now Specials are powerhouse power-weapons -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-26, 17:46
- But now Specials are powerhouse power-weapons -
ZackDark,
2016-04-26, 17:30
- Random ammo drops -
CyberKN,
2016-04-26, 17:03
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
ZackDark,
2016-04-26, 16:50
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Cody Miller,
2016-04-26, 16:07
- Divorce PvP and PvE -
unoudid,
2016-04-26, 16:40
- This. - ProbablyLast, 2016-04-27, 03:16
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. - Mid7night, 2016-04-26, 18:47
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
Xenos,
2016-04-27, 15:24
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 15:27
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
BeardFade,
2016-04-27, 15:53
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 16:10
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
ZackDark,
2016-04-27, 16:21
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. - CyberKN, 2016-04-27, 16:56
- A deeply held belief of mine... -
Korny,
2016-04-27, 16:26
- Nah, we're still playing on console, we need aim assist -
ZackDark,
2016-04-27, 17:31
- Plenty of console games have no aim assist. - Korny, 2016-04-27, 17:43
- Nah, we're still playing on console, we need aim assist -
ZackDark,
2016-04-27, 17:31
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
Claude Errera,
2016-04-27, 16:43
- Don't make me disown you Claude -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 16:55
- :D - Claude Errera, 2016-04-27, 17:13
- Don't make me disown you Claude -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 16:55
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
ZackDark,
2016-04-27, 16:21
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 16:10
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. - Funkmon, 2016-04-27, 17:24
- I agree that Sniper Rifles still aren't adjusted correctly. -
BeardFade,
2016-04-27, 15:53
- 19 months in, I'm still skeptical of Destiny's 3-gun system. -
MacAddictXIV,
2016-04-27, 15:27
- Controversial Alternative -
BeardFade,
2016-04-26, 15:48