What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... (Destiny)
I think the cutscene accomplished a few specific things by design:
- It showed that the Light started with and expanded out from the Traveler.
- It showed the Light specifically affecting Mercury, the Reef, and perhaps Saturn / Oryx's ship.
- It showed the Light touching everything in our galaxy and beyond.
- It showed the Pyramid Ships waking up after sensing the light and had them move back towards the Light's origin.
Your three main options each have their strengths but each fails to meet at least one of these criteria.
- A universe wide flash fails to show origin and direction and would still need followups to show specific locations being affected.
- Having the Light return to individuals / Ghosts directly could look really cool but would fail to show the Light touching the galaxy and might not have a reason to pass to the Pyramid Ships so you'd lose their awakening / moving towards the origin.
- A blinking dot on a screen could be combined with the Pyramid ships wakening up and moving in a direction, but it loses out on pretty much everything else. We wouldn't see Mercury affected or get a good sense that the Light touched the rest of the solar system and galaxy, for instance. Plus, you'd have to design a UI for that radar screen and having the first introduction to an alien race be the crappy alien clip art chosen by the underpaid temp alien programmer doesn't feel right to me. :p
The expanding sphere of Light might not make complete logical sense, but visually, it accomplishes a whole lot in a way that is very easily understood by the viewer. Was the cutscene perfect? No... it did very much leave the question open as to whether the rest of the Guardians got their light back, for one. But to call it lazy or a mistake... nah. I don't buy that at all.
So... in infuriating conclusion... your mother was a hamster, and your father smelled of elderberries. :)
Complete thread:
- Curse of Osiris - 1st live stream -
CougRon,
2017-11-15, 14:22
- Curse of Osiris - 1st live stream -
MacGyver10,
2017-11-15, 14:25
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 14:32
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
Schedonnardus,
2017-11-15, 14:43
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
bluerunner,
2017-11-15, 14:51
- +1 million - Robot Chickens, 2017-11-15, 14:57
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... - breitzen, 2017-11-16, 09:19
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
bluerunner,
2017-11-15, 14:51
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
Schedonnardus,
2017-11-15, 14:43
- Curse of Osiris - 1st live stream -
dogcow,
2017-11-15, 14:41
- Raid Lairs = New Mini Raids - Ragashingo, 2017-11-15, 15:10
- Not much was revealed that we didn't know... -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 14:32
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 14:34
- +100 -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 14:47
- +100 - Schedonnardus, 2017-11-15, 14:55
- #cheapLEYwasright -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-15, 16:18
- #cheapLEYwasright -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 23:30
- #cheapLEYwasright - cheapLEY, 2017-11-16, 07:58
- #cheapLEYwasright - Harmanimus, 2017-11-16, 09:50
- #cheapLEYwasright - cheapLEY, 2017-11-16, 15:02
- Finished. -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-17, 17:27
- Finished. - Korny, 2017-11-19, 14:09
- #cheapLEYwasright -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 23:30
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-15, 14:56
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 15:05
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 16:14
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-15, 16:36
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 18:58
- Managing expectations. -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-15, 19:26
- Managing expectations. -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 14:35
- Managing expectations. -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 15:04
- Managing expectations. - Ragashingo, 2017-11-16, 15:28
- Managing expectations. - Kahzgul, 2017-11-16, 17:02
- Managing expectations. -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 15:04
- Managing expectations. -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 14:35
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 19:31
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 21:05
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-16, 07:06
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Kahzgul, 2017-11-16, 10:59
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-16, 07:06
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 21:05
- Managing expectations. -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-15, 19:26
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 18:58
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Robot Chickens, 2017-11-15, 16:51
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-15, 16:36
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Cody Miller, 2017-11-15, 16:25
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 16:14
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Ragashingo, 2017-11-15, 15:19
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Xenos, 2017-11-15, 15:45
- your off your game Cody - electricpirate, 2017-11-15, 19:18
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Kermit, 2017-11-16, 07:04
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 15:05
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 15:16
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 15:38
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 18:23
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 19:17
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 19:45
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 21:00
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 10:05
- +1000 - Claude Errera, 2017-11-16, 10:41
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 10:53
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 11:37
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-16, 11:40
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it - Xenos, 2017-11-16, 11:44
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it - Kermit, 2017-11-16, 12:20
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:23
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 12:35
- Wait, what? - RaichuKFM, 2017-11-16, 13:22
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 12:35
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-16, 11:40
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word and not describing it -
Xenos,
2017-11-16, 11:37
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 10:05
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 21:00
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 19:45
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 19:17
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-15, 18:23
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-15, 15:38
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something -
electricpirate,
2017-11-15, 19:13
- Raid Lairs - I hate inventing a word to describe something - Kahzgul, 2017-11-15, 20:18
- +100 -
Korny,
2017-11-15, 14:47
- Let's talk about the first half of the stream - Kahzgul, 2017-11-15, 21:19
- Looks neat! - cheapLEY, 2017-11-16, 08:24
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
breitzen,
2017-11-16, 08:42
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 11:01
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
breitzen,
2017-11-16, 11:35
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! - Cody Miller, 2017-11-16, 11:42
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:01
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
breitzen,
2017-11-16, 12:06
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:18
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:24
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:35
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:52
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:59
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
marmot 1333,
2017-11-16, 13:08
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi - breitzen, 2017-11-16, 13:23
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-16, 13:56
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-16, 14:26
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-16, 14:31
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi - Ragashingo, 2017-11-16, 14:39
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-16, 15:04
- +1 - Robot Chickens, 2017-11-16, 16:33
- You mean besides all the obvious evidence of FTL comms? - ZackDark, 2017-11-16, 15:33
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Robot Chickens,
2017-11-16, 16:32
- I like this one. Good call - ZackDark, 2017-11-16, 16:43
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 16:56
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-17, 12:49
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 11:32
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-20, 11:44
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 13:37
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-20, 13:47
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 15:32
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-20, 22:15
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-21, 01:40
- Oh, hey, you gave me an idea - ZackDark, 2017-11-21, 05:04
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-21, 01:40
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-21, 10:31
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... - Kahzgul, 2017-11-21, 10:35
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-20, 22:15
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 15:32
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-20, 13:47
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 13:37
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-20, 11:44
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-20, 11:32
- What the heck guys!? Obviously it's... -
MacAddictXIV,
2017-11-17, 12:49
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Cody Miller,
2017-11-16, 14:31
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-16, 14:26
- Destiny never claimed to be hard sci-fi -
marmot 1333,
2017-11-16, 13:08
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:59
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:52
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:35
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-16, 15:18
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-17, 12:04
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-17, 21:10
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-18, 10:05
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! - Kahzgul, 2017-11-18, 17:12
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-18, 10:05
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-17, 21:10
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-17, 12:04
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 12:24
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Harmanimus,
2017-11-16, 12:18
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
breitzen,
2017-11-16, 12:06
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Ragashingo,
2017-11-16, 14:35
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 17:01
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-16, 17:51
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
ZackDark,
2017-11-16, 21:10
- +1000000000000^100000000000000 - Kahzgul, 2017-11-16, 22:41
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
ZackDark,
2017-11-16, 21:10
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
cheapLEY,
2017-11-16, 17:51
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 17:01
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
breitzen,
2017-11-16, 11:35
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! - Schedonnardus, 2017-11-16, 11:42
- Curse of Osiris is looking good! -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-16, 11:01
- Asking the real question here -
Up North 65,
2017-11-16, 18:51
- Asking the real question here - Kahzgul, 2017-11-16, 22:42
- Asking the real question here -
Robot Chickens,
2017-11-17, 10:21
- Asking the real question here -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-17, 11:00
- Asking the real question here -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-17, 12:25
- Asking the real question here -
Up North 65,
2017-11-17, 12:45
- Asking the real question here -
Xenos,
2017-11-17, 12:58
- Asking the real question here - Ragashingo, 2017-11-17, 13:48
- Asking the real question here -
Xenos,
2017-11-17, 12:58
- Asking the real question here - Kahzgul, 2017-11-17, 21:07
- Asking the real question here -
Up North 65,
2017-11-17, 12:45
- Asking the real question here -
RaichuKFM,
2017-11-17, 12:25
- Asking the real question here -
Kahzgul,
2017-11-17, 11:00
- Curse of Osiris - 1st live stream -
MacGyver10,
2017-11-15, 14:25