For fans of Journey: (Gaming)

by Cody Miller , Music of the Spheres - Never Forgot, Monday, December 17, 2018, 08:29 (1956 days ago) @ cheapLEY

Your Superman example is so off the mark. You are comparing a flight sim to a platformer.

I am comparing a 2D exploration platformer to a 3D one. Exploring a 3D world is more immersive than a 2D one if the genres are fully utilized.

You’re making my point for me. You didn’t even remotely come close to saying any of that. You said 3D is better than 2D and literally nothing else.

All other things being equal for a game about exploration 3D IS better than 2D.

You’re still wrong, but at least you presented and actual argument this time. (:

Here, I’ll fix my example. You think Super Mario Sunshine is better than Super Mario World? You think Twilight Princess is better than A Link to the Past? Because I don’t think either of those things are true.

Again, look at my ‘fully utilized’ Statement. You are comparing shit games to good ones. Try comparing a good 3D exploration game to a good 2D one. The 3D one will be better and more immersive.

If you give a master painter one color, and an idiot all the colors, you’d be saying one color painting is superior because that one came out better. See the problem with that way of thinking? Ask yourself what would happen if the master had all the colors.