A useful critique (Gaming)
by Cody Miller 
, Music of the Spheres - Never Forgot, Tuesday, April 15, 2025, 23:32 (3 days ago) @ Kermit
This is all just kind of criticism based on speculation about things we just don't know about yet. It's not necessarily the correct leap to go from "The reveal was bad" to "the game is underbaked".
I don't need to know every detail. In fact, I don't want to. I love the process of discovery for games. But I do need that hook. I just need to know "why should I care about this game?"
The reveal did not answer that.
Complete thread:
- New Marathon tease ... -
Kermit,
2025-04-03, 10:16
![[*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png "Open whole thread")
- New Marathon tease ... - ManKitten, 2025-04-03, 14:46
- I guess some music got out there too? -
CyberKN,
2025-04-03, 19:52
- Intel #2 - ManKitten, 2025-04-04, 05:45
- "Save the date" trailer for showcase on April 12th -
CyberKN,
2025-04-06, 16:24
- Love the art style!
![[ [ No text ] ]](themes/default/images/no_text.png "Empty posting / no text")
-
Kermit,
2025-04-06, 17:15
- Not in game -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-12, 14:47
- Not in game -
Kermit,
2025-04-12, 17:55
- Not in game - Cody Miller, 2025-04-13, 09:14
- Not in game -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 07:16
- Not in game - Vortech, 2025-04-13, 09:22
- Not in game - DavidIsDead, 2025-04-13, 12:21
- Not in game -
Kermit,
2025-04-12, 17:55
- Not in game -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-12, 14:47
- Bungie knows how to get me -
Beorn,
2025-04-07, 10:04
- Bungie knows how to get me -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-07, 10:10
- Bungie knows how to get me - Cody Miller, 2025-04-07, 12:53
- +1 - Coaxkez, 2025-04-07, 13:26
- Bungie knows how to get me - Vortech, 2025-04-12, 09:52
- Bungie knows how to get me -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-07, 10:10
- Love the art style!
- Tomorrow! -
Beorn,
2025-04-11, 20:16
- I’m excited! -
Kermit,
2025-04-12, 07:01
- +1 - Coaxkez, 2025-04-12, 07:38
- Today - Cody Miller, 2025-04-12, 07:28
- I’m excited! -
Kermit,
2025-04-12, 07:01
- Web Site Up - Vortech, 2025-04-12, 10:11
- :0 -
petetheduck,
2025-04-12, 17:51
- I just want to know . . . -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-12, 22:34
- Wait, what? -
Beorn,
2025-04-13, 06:10
- Wait, what? -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 07:15
- Welp. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 07:17
- Welp. -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 07:51
- Welp. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 08:03
- Welp. - cheapLEY, 2025-04-13, 08:51
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? -
Anna Komnene,
2025-04-13, 13:51
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 14:06
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? -
Anna Komnene,
2025-04-13, 15:38
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? - Coaxkez, 2025-04-13, 15:40
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? -
Anna Komnene,
2025-04-13, 15:38
- It's a multiplayer game. Does having a story matter at all? -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 14:06
- Welp. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 08:03
- Welp. -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 07:51
- Welp. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 07:17
- Wait, what? -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 07:15
- [citation needed desperately] - Coaxkez, 2025-04-13, 07:15
- Wait, what? -
Beorn,
2025-04-13, 06:10
- My feelings -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 07:45
- My feelings -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 08:11
- Another point - Coaxkez, 2025-04-13, 08:38
- My feelings - Vortech, 2025-04-13, 09:40
- My feelings -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 08:11
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 08:47
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 08:58
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 09:17
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Avateur,
2025-04-13, 09:33
- It was the presentation that was bad - Cody Miller, 2025-04-13, 09:48
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Vortech,
2025-04-13, 09:53
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 16:42
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 17:15
- I miss when games were just fun. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 19:03
- I miss when games were just fun. - cheapLEY, 2025-04-13, 19:53
- I miss when games were just fun. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-13, 19:03
- It was the presentation that was bad - Vortech, 2025-04-14, 12:27
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 17:15
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 16:42
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Avateur,
2025-04-13, 09:33
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 09:17
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Avateur,
2025-04-13, 09:21
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 09:56
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Vortech,
2025-04-13, 09:59
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 10:12
- It was the presentation that was bad -
squidnh3,
2025-04-13, 19:31
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 19:57
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 20:25
- It was the presentation that was bad - Kermit, 2025-04-14, 19:01
- It was the presentation that was bad - Vortech, 2025-04-14, 12:29
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 20:25
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 19:57
- It was the presentation that was bad -
squidnh3,
2025-04-13, 19:31
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 10:12
- It was the presentation that was bad -
Vortech,
2025-04-13, 09:59
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 09:56
- No thank you. -
ManKitten,
2025-04-13, 20:53
- No thank you. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 23:21
- No thank you. -
Vortech,
2025-04-14, 12:43
- No thank you. -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-14, 12:58
- No thank you. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-14, 14:35
- No thank you. - cheapLEY, 2025-04-14, 15:00
- No thank you. - Vortech, 2025-04-15, 08:17
- No thank you. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-14, 14:35
- No thank you. -
ManKitten,
2025-04-14, 14:54
- No thank you. - Avateur, 2025-04-14, 15:01
- No thank you. -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-14, 12:58
- No thank you. -
Vortech,
2025-04-14, 12:43
- No thank you. -
Coaxkez,
2025-04-14, 06:25
- No thank you. - cheapLEY, 2025-04-14, 06:31
- No thank you. - ManKitten, 2025-04-14, 08:31
- No thank you. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 23:21
- It was the presentation that was bad -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 08:58
- No proximity chat -
DavidIsDead,
2025-04-13, 13:17
- 👏🏻 -
Vortech,
2025-04-13, 14:08
- That sucks. -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-13, 14:38
- That sucks. -
Avateur,
2025-04-13, 20:23
- That sucks. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 20:29
- That sucks. - Avateur, 2025-04-14, 07:57
- That sucks. -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-13, 20:29
- That sucks. -
Avateur,
2025-04-13, 20:23
- 👏🏻
- That UI -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-14, 06:29
- That UI -
ManKitten,
2025-04-14, 08:32
- That UI -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-14, 11:28
- I thought it was on purpose here -
ZackDark,
2025-04-15, 02:34
- I thought it was on purpose here -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-15, 08:10
- I thought it was on purpose here -
ZackDark,
2025-04-15, 15:41
- I thought it was on purpose here -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-15, 16:11
- Almost 100% on purpose - ChrisTheeCrappy, 2025-04-16, 10:48
- I thought it was on purpose here -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-15, 16:11
- I thought it was on purpose here -
ZackDark,
2025-04-15, 15:41
- I thought it was on purpose here -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-15, 08:10
- I thought it was on purpose here -
ZackDark,
2025-04-15, 02:34
- That UI -
Vortech,
2025-04-15, 08:20
- That UI - ManKitten, 2025-04-15, 08:59
- That UI -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-14, 11:28
- That UI -
ManKitten,
2025-04-14, 08:32
- Terminals - Cody Miller, 2025-04-14, 11:41
- This kinda sells it: -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-14, 12:15
- This kinda sells it: - Avateur, 2025-04-14, 15:11
- SPOILER - Coaxkez, 2025-04-14, 15:27
- I don't know about this game... - Kermit, 2025-04-14, 17:58
- The revolution will not be televised… at launch - Cody Miller, 2025-04-15, 12:15
- THE OG -
Cody Miller,
2025-04-15, 12:53
- Thanks! -
Kermit,
2025-04-15, 14:45
- Thanks!
- Two cents -
CyberKN,
2025-04-15, 16:14
- Two cents - Cody Miller, 2025-04-15, 16:16
- A useful critique -
Kermit,
2025-04-15, 20:33
- A useful critique - Coaxkez, 2025-04-15, 20:42
- A useful critique -
cheapLEY,
2025-04-15, 22:17
- A useful critique -
Kermit,
2025-04-16, 09:21
- A useful critique -
ManKitten,
2025-04-16, 12:16
- A useful critique - Cody Miller, 2025-04-16, 13:25
- A useful critique -
ManKitten,
2025-04-16, 12:16
- A useful critique -
Kermit,
2025-04-16, 09:21
- A useful critique - Cody Miller, 2025-04-15, 23:32
- A useful critique -
squidnh3,
2025-04-16, 07:40
- A useful critique - Cody Miller, 2025-04-16, 10:18
- Bungie drops NDA requirement for Alpha - Cody Miller, 2025-04-18, 13:04
- Alpha Invites Going Out -
Beorn,
2025-04-18, 18:52
- :( -
Vortech,
2025-04-18, 18:54
- :(