Wasn't a fan of Part II's story because... (Fan Creations)
by Cody Miller 
, Music of the Spheres - Never Forgot, Sunday, January 22, 2023, 11:07 (452 days ago) @ Anna Komnene
I don't like stories about assholes, and Part II turned Ellie into one huge asshole. Justifications aside, it's just not my thing. Despite Joel being an asshole in Part 1, I was able to get on board because: one, I enjoyed the gameplay, and that's the most important thing in a game to me; two, I really enjoyed Ellie; and three, they were ultimately trying to do something good.
Part II? I hate Part II for making me hate a character I really enjoyed. It's not the sort of character development I like, it's just not what I look for in my stories personally.
That being said, if Part III comes out and I enjoy it, then I'm willing to forget Part II ever existed, and Ellie lost her fingers from an infected person (ugh -- that reminds me of Halsey losing her arms in the Halo series).
One critic was talking to their gay friend about Ellie and representation in games, and she said "Actually, I don't want representation in this shitty world full or shitty people".
Complete thread:
- Early Praise for The Last of Us -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-10, 02:42
![[*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png "Open whole thread")
- Side Question / Sub Topic -
ManKitten,
2023-01-10, 05:54
- Side Question / Sub Topic - ZackDark, 2023-01-10, 14:33
- Side Question / Sub Topic - Joe Duplessie (SNIPE 316), 2023-01-11, 05:35
- Side Question / Sub Topic -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-11, 09:57
- Side Question / Sub Topic -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-11, 10:32
- Side Question / Sub Topic - ManKitten, 2023-01-11, 11:02
- Side Question / Sub Topic -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-11, 10:32
- Episode 1 -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-15, 19:55
- Episode 1 - cheapLEY, 2023-01-15, 20:07
- Episode 1 -
Claude Errera,
2023-01-16, 09:17
- Episode 1 -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-16, 10:25
- Episode 1 -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 18:56
- P.S. -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 19:31
- P.S. -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-16, 20:53
- P.S. -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 22:02
- I think they nailed it -
Beorn,
2023-01-18, 22:26
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 09:21
- I think they nailed it -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-19, 09:31
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 09:36
- I think they nailed it -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-19, 10:02
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 10:06
- I think they nailed it - cheapLEY, 2023-01-21, 12:32
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 10:06
- I think they nailed it -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-19, 10:02
- I think they nailed it - Cody Miller, 2023-01-19, 13:05
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 09:36
- I think they nailed it -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-19, 09:31
- I think they nailed it -
Kermit,
2023-01-19, 09:21
- I think they nailed it -
Beorn,
2023-01-18, 22:26
- P.S. -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 22:02
- P.S. -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-16, 20:53
- P.S. -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 19:31
- Episode 1 -
Kermit,
2023-01-16, 18:56
- Episode 1 -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-16, 10:25
- Joel was never given a redemption -
Anna Komnene,
2023-01-21, 15:43
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
Korny,
2023-01-21, 16:29
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-21, 20:19
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
EffortlessFury,
2023-01-21, 21:38
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-21, 22:04
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
EffortlessFury,
2023-01-23, 11:05
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) - cheapLEY, 2023-01-23, 12:13
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
EffortlessFury,
2023-01-23, 11:05
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-21, 22:04
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
EffortlessFury,
2023-01-21, 21:38
- Wasn't a fan of Part II's story because... -
Anna Komnene,
2023-01-22, 10:46
- Wasn't a fan of Part II's story because... - Cody Miller, 2023-01-22, 11:07
- Wasn't a fan of Part II's story because... - cheapLEY, 2023-01-22, 17:52
- Wasn't a fan of Part II's story because... - EffortlessFury, 2023-01-23, 11:11
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
cheapLEY,
2023-01-21, 20:19
- Joel was never given a redemption - Cody Miller, 2023-01-22, 08:46
- Joel was never given a redemption (*Part II spoilz*) -
Korny,
2023-01-21, 16:29
- Episode 2 -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-22, 22:23
- Dustin Echoes -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-23, 12:47
- Dustin Echoes -
Claude Errera,
2023-01-23, 13:04
- Dustin Echoes - ZackDark, 2023-01-23, 13:27
- Dustin Echoes - cheapLEY, 2023-01-23, 14:14
- Dustin Echoes - Cody Miller, 2023-01-23, 18:00
- Dustin Echoes -
Claude Errera,
2023-01-23, 13:04
- Episode 2 -
Kermit,
2023-01-23, 19:04
- Episode 2 - cheapLEY, 2023-01-23, 19:19
- Dustin Echoes -
Cody Miller,
2023-01-23, 12:47
- Episode 3 - Cody Miller, 2023-01-30, 17:42
- Episode 4 -
Cody Miller,
2023-02-06, 16:30
- Episode 4 - Kermit, 2023-02-06, 17:13
- Episode 4--Wheel Spinning -
cheapLEY,
2023-02-06, 17:35
- Episode 4--Wheel Spinning - Cody Miller, 2023-02-06, 17:40
- Episode 5 - Cody Miller, 2023-02-13, 19:10
- The Ebert Trap - Cody Miller, 2023-02-20, 08:17
- The failure of The Last of Us show. -
cheapLEY,
2023-03-05, 19:39
- The failure of The Last of Us show. -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-05, 22:54
- The failure of The Last of Us show. - Korny, 2023-03-06, 10:35
- The failure of The Last of Us show. -
Kermit,
2023-03-06, 10:23
- I think the story is rushed -
Anna Komnene,
2023-03-06, 14:49
- This - ZackDark, 2023-03-06, 15:32
- I think the story is rushed -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-06, 15:51
- I think the story is rushed -
Anna Komnene,
2023-03-07, 08:11
- I think the story is rushed - cheapLEY, 2023-03-07, 08:30
- I think the story is rushed -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-07, 09:49
- I think the story is rushed -
Kermit,
2023-03-07, 13:32
- I think the story is rushed -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-07, 13:42
- I think the story is rushed -
Kermit,
2023-03-07, 14:15
- I think the story is rushed -
cheapLEY,
2023-03-07, 15:34
- I think the story is rushed - Cody Miller, 2023-03-07, 15:58
- I think the story is rushed -
cheapLEY,
2023-03-07, 15:34
- I think the story is rushed -
Kermit,
2023-03-07, 14:15
- I think the story is rushed -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-07, 13:42
- I think the story is rushed -
Anna Komnene,
2023-03-08, 09:11
- I think the story is rushed - Cody Miller, 2023-03-08, 12:01
- I think the story is rushed -
Kermit,
2023-03-07, 13:32
- I think the story is rushed -
Anna Komnene,
2023-03-07, 08:11
- I think the story is rushed -
Anna Komnene,
2023-03-06, 14:49
- The failure of The Last of Us show. -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-05, 22:54
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-12, 23:32
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-13, 09:40
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 10:40
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-13, 11:15
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 11:40
- The Finale - Kermit, 2023-03-13, 11:50
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 11:40
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-13, 11:15
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 10:40
- The Finale -
Korny,
2023-03-13, 11:29
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 11:36
- The Finale - Kermit, 2023-03-13, 11:54
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-13, 11:36
- The Finale -
cheapLEY,
2023-03-13, 16:38
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-14, 10:48
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-14, 11:29
- The Finale - Kermit, 2023-03-14, 11:47
- The Finale -
Cody Miller,
2023-03-14, 11:29
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-14, 10:48
- A general complaint - Kermit, 2023-03-15, 09:24
- The Finale -
Kermit,
2023-03-13, 09:40
- Side Question / Sub Topic -
ManKitten,
2023-01-10, 05:54